
One of the most common knocks against Tiger Woods' illustrious PGA Tour career is that even if he passes Jack Nicklaus in major tournament victories, he never had to play against the same stiff level of competition. Jack had to face off against the likes of Arnold Palmer, Tom Watson and Gary Player. Old time golf fans proclaim this argument with the same conviction of a priest quoting scripture from the Bible. But is there any truth behind it?
First, when comparing career competitors, I observed that the most common mistake those who believe Nicklaus faced tougher opponents make is to compare the career numbers of his rivals as opposed to where they stood when Jack was around the same age as Tiger is currently in 2009 (33). The only fair and logical method for comparing these two dominant golfers from different eras is to examine the playing field in 1973 when Jack was 33 years old, because while we know what his rivals did for the remainder of his career, we have no idea what Phil Mickelson, Padraig Harrington or other opponents of Tiger will do over the next decade or so.
Before digging into opponent statistics, let's compare 2009 Tiger to 1973 Jack...
Tiger Woods: 14 majors (4 Masters, 3 US Open, 3 British Open, 4 PGA Championship).
Jack Nicklaus: 11 majors (4 Masters, 3 US Open, 2 British Open, 2 PGA Championship).
Now for the opponents, comparing golfers who won multiple majors and played against Tiger to golfers who won multiple majors and played against Jack as they stood in early 1973...
Tiger's Opponents as of early 2009
Phil Mickelson (3 majors)
Vijay Singh (3 majors)
Padraig Harrington (3 majors)
Ernie Els (3 majors, 2 against Tiger)
Payne Stewart (3 majors, 1 against Tiger)
Angel Cabrera (2 majors)
José María Olazábal (2 majors, 1 against Tiger)
Mark O'Meara (2 majors)
Retief Goosen (2 majors)
Lee Janzen (2 majors, 1 against Tiger)
John Daly (2 majors, 0 against Tiger)